Annual Meeting Peer Review Process - Attend Events
Skip to content
Facebook
Twitter
Blog
LinkedIn
Instagram
YouTube
Search
Login Communities Publications About AAA Contact Join Donate Shop FAQs
Melissa Harris Perry at AAA 2016
Melissa Harris Perry at AAA 2016

In This Section

Annual Meeting Peer Review Process

From Our Sponsors

In This Section

Have you ever wondered what happens to your submitted scholarly session proposal after the submission deadline; how the final Annual Meeting Program is determined; or how the peer review process is conducted? Keep reading to find out!

Who is responsible for conducting the peer review?
Representatives from each section, known as the Section Program Chairs, conduct the peer review of proposal submissions directed to their respective section. The American Anthropological Association thanks the 2019 Program Chairs who will enhance the AAA Annual Meeting through the volunteering of their time.

Do all session types undergo peer review?
No. Below are the various submission/session types that undergo section peer review:

Demystifying the Annual Meeting Peer Review Process
The review process consists of three (3) review “rounds,” all of which are detailed below.

After all three of the review rounds have been completed, the decisions from all three rounds are compiled by the AAA Meetings Department in preparation for the scheduling phase.

Scheduling
AAA staff do not review or evaluate section submissions, or participate in the section’s peer review process. Once the review period concludes, the top 50% of scores from within each section are given an A-grade; the next 30% of top-scoring proposals are given a B-grade; and the bottom 20 percent are given a C-grade.

In June, the Executive Program Committee Chair and Chair Elect will visit the AAA office to populate the Annual Meeting program in the following order, until the program is full –

Accept/decline notifications are sent to all submitters in mid July, and a preliminary Annual Meeting program will be released in mid-August.

Questions?
AAA does not collect or release reviewer comments. AAA encourages interested individuals to contact the Section Program Chairs directly with questions regarding the reviewing of their submission(s).



You Might Also Like